The importance of markers in the evaluation of probiotics

18 May 2024

The importance of markers in the evaluation of probiotics

 

 Intestinal health is one of the most relevant topics in poultry farming in recent years. There are several factors that play a role in intestinal health, with the most important ones being related to microbiota, nutrition, and host response (intestinal integrity and inflammation)..
  • However, evaluating and predicting intestinal health is very complex and often inaccurate.

Nevertheless, intestinal markers are necessary for:

Predicting performance issues

Assessing the effectiveness of intestinal health strategies

biozyme robapagina
BANNER de LALLEMAND

Justifying production interventions

Testing nutritional changes and new diagnostic tools

 

Nuproxa international 07-2023
banner special nutrients
BANNER de LALLEMAND
biozyme robapagina

In the field, several markers related to intestinal health have been used to help monitor the health status of poultry.

However, the effectiveness of these markers remains debated, mainly due to the difficulty of establishing scientific criteria and the challenges in setting up an ideal and statistically acceptable sample.

Moreover, some of these markers have a low direct correlation with the parameters.

However, some markers have been extensively tested and used, providing users with greater confidence, especially because they have a proven scientific basis.

The objective of this article is to review some methodologies for assessing intestinal health in poultry and to discuss how the effects of the probiotic Alterion®, an exclusive strain of Bacillus subtilis (29784), have been demonstrated in modulating these markers of intestinal health.

Macroscopic scoring

In general, evaluation and classification through macroscopic scoring are conducted after the death or sacrifice of sick animals. However, in poultry farming, performing necropsies to monitor health status is common and extremely important for disease diagnosis and control.

Various scoring methodologies can be observed in the field. However, the methodology published by Teirlynck et al. (2011) has been shown to be simple to apply and easy to control.

Furthermore, the scoring system for macroscopic lesions showed a negative correlation with villus length and a positive correlation with T lymphocyte infiltration in dysbiosis situations (Figure 1a and 1b).

Figure 1a. Correlation of macroscopic scoring with villus length and T lymphocyte infiltration 

Villus length (μm) in duodenal sections (Y) in relation to macroscopic scoring (X)

 

Figure 1b. Correlation of macroscopic scoring with T lymphocyte infiltration

T lymphocyte infiltration (percentage of area) in duodenal and cecal sections (Y) in relation to macroscopic scoring (X)

Using the methodology of Teirlynck et al., a nutritional challenge test was conducted by including 20% rye, inducing an increase in the content of NSP (non-starch polysaccharides) in the diets, and subsequently the effects of the probiotic Alterion® (Bacillus subtilis 29784) were evaluated.

The score for bacterial enteritis was reduced to 1.0 in the animals of the Alterion® group, whereas the animals in the control group (only challenged with NSP) maintained a score of 2.0 (Figure 2).

This study demonstrated that it is possible to verify the effects of the probiotic Alterion® using a macroscopic scoring evaluation methodology.

Figure 2: Alterion® (Bs 29784) decreases macroscopic scoring in broilers challenged with high levels of non-starch polysaccharides (NSP)

Some methodologies have been developed to facilitate histological evaluation by applying scoring systems for different parameters of the intestinal mucosa, such as:

Indeed, histomorphological evaluations of the intestine can help assess epithelial integrity and inflammation (Gholamiandehkordi et al., 2007).

Furthermore, some studies associate increased villus height, lamina propria thickness, and epithelial cell count with higher body weight in birds (Kraieski et al., 2017).

In studies conducted with the probiotic Alterion®, we observed a significant increase in villus length compared to the control group (without intestinal health additives) in:

Table 1 summarizes the results found (Jacquier et al., 2019).

Table 1: Morphology of the ileum and cecum in 42-day-old broilers supplemented with Alterion® (Table adapted from Jacquier et al., 2019).

a, b means within a line without a common superscript differ significantly (P <0.05). SEM = Standard Error of the Mean.

However, we know that simple morphometric analyses are not sufficient to evaluate the integrity status of the intestinal epithelium.

Specifically, notable is the decrease in the thickness of the lamina propria and mucosal epithelium, as well as the reduction of inflammatory infiltration in these two regions (Figure 3; Tirano et al., 2019).

These results confirm the potential of the probiotic Alterion® to improve integrity and modulate epithelial inflammation in situations with or without challenge.

 

Figure 3: Effects of Alterion® on microscopic ISI scoring in 14-day-old broilers challenged under the necrotic enteritis model

1st image: Control (Challenged without additives); 2nd image: Challenged+Alterion; 3rd image: Challenged+Enramycin. EPT: Epithelial Thickness; LPT: Lamina Propria Thickness; OOC: Oocysts; PROL: Enterocyte Proliferation; TOT: Total Score. Different letters in each parameter indicate statistical differences (p<0.05).

Figure 4: Alterion® decreases ISI score in broilers challenged with necrotic enteritis

Legend: Control: Challenged; Alterion: Challenged + Alterion®; Enramycin: Challenged + Enramycin. The lower total score observed in the group that consumed Alterion® indicates less inflammation and a more intact intestinal mucosa structure.

 

Intestinal  microbiota

Intestinal microbiota analysis in birds continues to be considered a complex and of limited utility tool in the daily routine of the poultry industry.

The microbiota can be classified as resistant when the microbial population has higher diversity and a greater number of bacteria with anti-inflammatory properties (butyrate-producing bacteria such as Ruminococcaceae spp and Lachnospiraceae spp) and fewer opportunistic pathogens like Clostridium perfringens and Enterobacteriaceae spp, as well as Salmonella spp and Escherichia coli.

Several studies have demonstrated the benefits of increasing Firmicutes or enhancing the Firmicutes/Bacteroidetes ratios.

Among the butyrate-producing Firmicutes, the decrease in the population of Faecalibacterium prausnitzii stands out, which proves to be an important marker in specific pathogenic situations.

In a necrotic enteritis challenge model, the probiotic Alterion® was observed to increase the alpha diversity of the intestinal microbiota (Chao and Shannon indices) compared to the control group (without additives).

It was also observed a higher prevalence of Ruminococcaceae (P>0.001 – Table 2) with Alterion® supplementation, specifically an increase in Faecalibacterium prausnitzii (+13.4%; P<0.001). As mentioned, this bacterium has been correlated with intestinal health parameters such as villus length and CD3 lymphocyte area.

Furthermore, we observed an increase in the prevalence of bacteria from the genus Ruminococcus and Lachnoclostridium (Table 2), which are responsible for breaking down non-starch polysaccharides into short-chain fatty acids, such as butyrate (an important molecule in epithelial regeneration with anti-inflammatory effects).

In another experiment where broilers were challenged with C. perfringens, it was observed that the number of E. coli on day 21 and the number of C. perfringens on day 28 of the birds’ life significantly reduced in the group that consumed the probiotic.

Figure 5: Microbiota diversity in cecal content samples of broilers supplemented with Alterion® (adapted from Keerqin et al., 2021)

Control: Control without challenge/additive; NE: Necrotic enteritis challenge; Alterion® + NE: Alterion® + Necrotic Enteritis; Atb + NE: Antibiotic promoter + Necrotic Enteritis.

 

Table 2: Effects of the probiotic Alterion® on the cecal microbiota (table adapted from Jacquier et al. 2019; Poultry Science 98:2548-54).

Bacteria from the families Lachnospiraceae and Ruminococcaceae are associated with butyrate production, a molecule involved in the modulation of intestinal inflammation and re-epithelialization. The decrease in the genus Bacteroides is related to an increase in the Firmicutes/Bacteroidetes ratio (control group=1.66; Alterion® group=3.17), which has been associated with increased poultry weight gain (Jacquier et al., 2019).

 

Microbial metabolites

Finally, we cannot forget about microbial metabolites, which can also be related to intestinal health.

Other metabolites are associated with intestinal integrity, such as hypoxanthine, pantothenate, and nicotinic acid, which are closely related to the control of inflammatory processes and tissue restoration.

 

Figure 6: Nicotinic acid modulates inflammation in the intestines of birds(adapted from Singh et al. 2014; Immunity. 16; 40(1): 128-139).

It has been demonstrated that nicotinic acid increases enterocyte proliferation and epithelial “healing” in an in vitro model with CaCo2 cells.

Figure 7: Nicotinic acid content in the ileum and jejunum of broilers supplemented or not with Alterion®

Numerous molecular technologies have been developed to support the understanding of intestinal health, such as metagenomics, metabolomics, metatranscriptomics, etc.; they currently form part of the research focus of numerous research groups and companies in the poultry field.

Nonetheless, due to the complexity of the poultry gut, replicating these methodologies in the field poses a significant challenge for poultry professionals.

In summary, this article has reviewed some of the important markers of intestinal health in poultry, which can be used both in academic research and practical field applications. Evaluating the effects of a nutritional additive on intestinal health requires the use of various tools and markers, as a single factor does not seem to be sufficient to assess the intestinal health status of a bird.

As we can see, several markers can already guide us in various strategies for monitoring intestinal integrity and even in the evaluation of probiotic products.

Revealingly, we have demonstrated that all these markers could be used to evaluate and test the consistency of the Alterion® probiotic as a tool to reinforce intestinal integrity, as well as to modulate inflammation and the microbiota.

banner basf
BANNER de LALLEMAND
biozyme robapagina
lallemandanimalnutrition eng
Related with Additives
Latest posts about Additives
banner basf
Subscribe Now!
lallemandanimalnutrition eng
banner special nutrients

MAGAZINE NUTRINEWS INTERNATIONAL

Subscribe now to the technical magazine of animal nutrition

JOIN OUR NUTRITIONAL COMMUNITY

Access to articles in PDF
Stay up to date with our newsletters
Receive the magazine for free in digital version

DISCOVER
AgriFM - Los podcast del sector ganadero en español
agriCalendar - El calendario de eventos del mundo agroganaderoagriCalendar
agrinewsCampus - Cursos de formación para el sector de la ganadería